What Comes Next For Precious Metals?
The below report was created for Monex Precious Metals. We would like to thank Monex for making this CPM Group report available free of charge.
The below report was created for Monex Precious Metals. We would like to thank Monex for making this CPM Group report available free of charge. Visit them at www.monex.com to learn how they can help you with your precious metals investment needs.
The first half of 2024 was good for precious metals, particularly gold and silver. Gold prices were up 13% at the end of June 2024 from the end of 2023 and silver prices were up 21% during the same period. Platinum prices have essentially been flat during the first half of 2024, supported by strength in gold and silver as well as concerns about supply. However, soft platinum fabrication demand expectations for this year as well as into the medium term have been acting as headwinds for platinum prices. The sentiment toward palladium remains negative, with prices for the metal down around 12% during the first six months of this year.
The strength in gold and silver can be explained by the numerous risks to the global economy and financial system from monetary policy, fiscal policy, and political risk, for which these metals are used as hedges in investor portfolios.
On the economic side, inflation has been a centerpiece over the past few years. The rate of inflation growth has decelerated from the multi-decade highs that were seen in 2022 but still stands above targets set by various central banks. At the start of 2024 inflation data raised concerns that inflation was making a comeback. More recently released data is suggesting that inflation is back on its downward trajectory.
Mixed inflation, employment, and other economic data limit the Fed’s confidence in the downward trajectory, however. The Fed has held the Federal Funds target range between 5.25% and 5.50% since July 2023. The Fed’s most recent projections show a 25 basis point cut to rates later this year. Meanwhile, markets expect the Fed to cut twice later this year. There is a risk that these cuts do not occur. A healthy jobs market gives that Fed some flexibility with holding rates at present levels and ensuring that it completely quells the risk of inflation, especially given the signs that inflation has become more sticky in recent months.
While a lot of the risks in financial markets are already priced into precious metals, one factor that has not been fully priced in is the outcomes of various elections still to come especially in Europe and the U.S. The outcomes of these elections in the U.S. and Europe, which could bring in governments with protectionist and anti-immigrant agendas, complicate decision making for central banks. If more protectionist governments were to come to power, there is a renewed risk of inflation rising in response to the imposition of trade tariffs. Possible anti-immigrant policies could also slow economic growth, forcing the hand of central banks to lower rates at a time when inflation has not been fully controlled. The possibility of slower growth and higher inflation bode well for precious metals investments, especially gold and silver.
Precious metals prices are expected to strengthen during the second half of this year. While prices are projected to move sideways to slightly lower in July and August, beyond that precious metals prices, particularly gold and silver, should be expected to rise. While the labor market still is strong, there are other signs in the economic data that suggest a slowing economy, weighed down by current interest rates. This weakness could continue to gather over the next several months, which coupled with political risk should bode well for gold and silver prices. Both metals are expected to experience a double-digit increase in annual average prices during 2024. A slowdown in global vehicle demand this year, meanwhile, is expected to weigh on platinum and palladium prices.
Precious metals markets typically enter a period of seasonal weakness during the summer. Manufacturers, jewelers, and investors often reduce their buying of precious metals during these months, leading to some softening of prices. Often the price weakness maybe more subtle, in the form of a headwind to precious metals prices rising rather than an outright decline, at least not any meaningful decline.
Seasonal patterns are easily and often overridden by events, either in the markets themselves or more often in the economic, financial, and political environments that condition trends in fabrication demand and investment demand.
CPM expects seasonal demand patterns may becalm precious metals prices to some small extent this year, from June through August, but that the panoply of political issues confronting the United States and the world, along with slowing economic growth in most countries and fiscal policy constraints seem likely to create an environment in the final four months of 2024 and into 2025 in which investors sharply increase their demand for gold and silver as safer havens for their wealth and protection against these hostile political, social, and economic conditions, pushing the prices of both metals sharply higher. New record highs in gold seem assured in such an environment, and new record intraday and annual average silver prices also appear to be well within reach.
This expectation of CPM Group sets near-term precious metals price forecasts to move in a sideways fashion at elevated levels, at least in the case of gold and silver, rather than some sharp correction in prices. Platinum and palladium prices too are expected to move sideways, but their price levels cannot be referred to as elevated, especially compared to where they have been in recent years.
As can be seen in seasonality charts for all the four metals, there is a distinct seasonal pattern across these markets. Typically, there is price strength during the first five months of the year followed by a weakness in prices between June and August. Prices generally soften as industrial users, jewelers, and investors take vacations and reduce their demand. While the strength during the first five months and the pace of recovery during the last four months differs among the metals, the weakness during June through August is quite consistent across the metals. For this reason, it is quite likely that this seasonal weakness will play out this year as well. That said, it is likely to be less intense than what the seasonal charts may suggest. It is not unusual to have seasonal patterns overridden by events, by economic developments, political conditions, and fundamentals specific to individual markets.
This year could be one of those years when political and economic factors may override seasonality. As mentioned before, while seasonal weakness may not be completely eliminated it is expected to be less intense. There is a lot of political and economic uncertainty, which may keep investors interested in adding precious metals, especially gold and silver, to their portfolios as hedge against these risks.
While some price weakness is to be expected, CPM Group’s analysis suggests that investors are sufficiently concerned about future economic trends and a host of international political issues and domestic divisions in many countries around the world. Given these exogenous factors, CPM expects investors to continue to buy gold and silver and will take advantage of the current and any further dips over the next three months to add to their holdings. The mild price declines expected in the precious metals complex are not enough for longer-term investors to liquidate long positions. It may be enough to warrant short-term hedges, but the expectation is that any weakness may be limited this year.
Markets In Summary
Gold prices have been moving mostly sideways with a slight downside bias, since the fourth week of May. Gold prices have strong support at the $2,300 level, with prices rebounding from around this level on several occasions over the course of June but not breaking below it.
Economic indicators are mixed, which is resulting in the flip flopping in investor sentiments and thus gold prices that has been observed over the past month. On balance though it seems that the indicators are supportive of gold prices in the recent range or higher. While economic conditions are not outright weak, it is clear that there has been a loss in economic momentum that over the past few years. This was to be expected given the more restrictive monetary policy and the pull back in fiscal support post covid.
Monetary policy is expected to remain restrictive until the Fed gains more confidence that inflation is on a sustainable downward trajectory or when economic conditions show more consistent signs of deterioration. While the Fed is not interested in engineering a recession it is presently more focused on containing inflation, which can be harder to constrain, than reviving a flagging economy if it should spiral downward.
The longer monetary policy remains restrictive the greater the probability that something in the economy or financial system breaks, which is supportive of gold. In addition to monetary policy, and what CPM Group thinks to be a more important factor, political risk both in the United States but also in other countries has the potential to break something in the global economy or financial system. As mentioned in the front section of this report, the move globally toward more protectionist governments is a risk to both inflation as well as economic growth.
With these risks running in the political realm, gold prices are unlikely to see any meaningful weakness in the foreseeable future. There will be periods from time to time when gold prices soften in reaction to some good economic news, but there seems little in the form of news both political or economic that is likely to cause gold prices to weaken sharply any time soon.
On the downside, gold prices, as mentioned above, have strong support around the $2,304 level both over the next couple of months and longer term. If gold prices are able to break and settle below this level, it could cause gold prices to weaken toward $2,285. There is a small probability that gold prices soften toward $2,165. Such weakness is likely to be driven by seasonal or technical factors rather than fundamentals. There seems a very limited risk that economic or political risks decline sufficiently over the next few months to warrant such a decline. Given the seasonal or technical reasons behind such possible weaknesses, the decline is likely to be short-lived and if it does occur should be used as a buying opportunity.
On the upside, meanwhile, gold prices are likely to face meaningful resistance over the next couple months, around $2,400 or $2,465 on a spike. While gold prices are expected to rise above this level later this year, over the next two months breaking above this level could become challenging.
During July and August gold prices seem most likely to move sideways between $2,300 and $2,400, with some possibility of breaking out of this range. Dramatic or melodramatic U.S. political developments could push gold higher toward $2,465, however. Beyond the next two months, gold prices are likely to be more firmly on a path higher.
One of the factors that has been supportive of gold prices during the first half of this year, in addition to the political and economic factors discussed above, has been healthy buying by central banks. During the first five months of this year these entities reported purchasing 3.42 million ounces of gold on a net basis. These entities have been price sensitive, historically. While central banks have been net buyers during the first five months of this year, their net purchases have been showing signs of weakness as prices have risen, with the monthly total acquisitions declining. For example, at the end of April, reported net purchases by central banks were at 4.38 million ounces, which had slid to net purchases of 3.42 million ounces at the end of May. Central banks were net buyers of 364,000 ounces, 2.1 million ounces, 200,000 ounces, and 2.1 million ounces during January, February, March, and April, respectively. In May, central banks were net sellers of 1.37 million ounces.
The People’s Bank Of China (PBOC), which has been a consistent buyer of gold since November 2022, has been reducing its monthly net purchases during the first four months of this year. In May 2024 the PBOC reported no purchases for the first time in 18 months.
The central banks of Kazakhstan and Turkey, which had been net buyers in the period between January and April 2024, reduced their holdings in May by 368,000 ounces and 40,000 ounces, respectively. These two central banks remained net buyers of gold for the first five months of 2024 in total, however.
The Russian central bank too was a seller in May, of 1.35 million ounces. At the end of May, the Russian central bank was a net seller of 92,000 ounces for the first five months of 2024. There has been a lot of volatility in the Russian central bank’s gold holdings as the country wages a war against Ukraine. The net sales during the first five months for this year do not necessarily suggest the start of a trend of net selling. As an example, the Russian central bank was a net seller of 1.2 million ounces in January 2024 and a net buyer of 2.45 million ounces between February and April.
While several central banks sold or paused purchases during May in response to high gold prices, there were a few central banks that were net buyer even in May. The most notable of these was the central bank of Poland. The Polish central bank added 331,000 ounces of gold to its holdings during May, taking its net purchases during the first four months of 2024 to 481,000 ounces.
It should be noted that gold prices were at record high levels in May and have since retreated, moving in a mostly sideways fashion. June data for central bank net purchases may show renewed buying interest among these entities. While central banks are price sensitive, they have continued adding gold to their holdings in a high gold price environment, as has been observed over the past few years. Both sideways price moves, as have been seen over the course of June, or any potential weakness will most likely be treated as a buying opportunity by these entities as they continue to diversify their reserve assets.
Silver prices declined over the course of June, after reaching multi-year highs in May. The rapid decline in silver prices relative to gold resulted in the monthly average gold:silver price ratio rising once again during June. During June, the ratio had risen to 79.4, after falling to 75.1 in May, its lowest level since October 2021.
Silver prices are expected to rise in the medium term, and their gains are expected to be sharper than gold, especially on account of the metal’s recent underperformance relative to gold. Gold prices have broken several record highs during the first half of 2024 while silver prices have been struggling to sustain gains over $30 and trading well below their record high levels reached in April 2011.
One of the biggest challenges that silver prices face is the selling by past investors who bought in anticipation of silver prices far in excess of the record levels reached in 2011. While the gains in silver prices over the past five years have been impressive and extremely profitable for silver investors, other investors who had overly inflated silver price expectations have been getting out of their positions either at breakeven or at a loss rather than continue to have their money tied up in silver for the next time silver prices reach record levels. Such selling could continue for some time, with many investors having bought at levels above $30. Once these investors are done with selling, it will allow silver prices to rise more strongly. May 2024 was the first time that silver prices rose above $30 since February 2021.
Silver prices are expected to move sideways with strong support for prices around $28.30. Seasonal weakness in prices could force silver toward this support. Given the mixed nature of economic data being released at this time any particularly positive economic data could also reduce investor desire to increase holdings of safe haven assets like silver. If prices break the $28.30 support level, there could be a brief period where silver prices slip to $26.22.
Given the possibility of generally higher political and economic risk during the last four months of this year any decline in prices to those levels seem likely to be treated by some investors as a buying opportunity, shortening the period for which silver prices will linger at lower levels. Silver prices are most likely to move sideways between $28.30 and $33, with a slight possibility that prices break above the $33 level.
Platinum prices essentially finished June at the same price as where they started the month. On 3 June platinum prices settled at $1,022; prices settled at $1,014 on 28 June. During the first half of the month platinum prices declined, slipping to $945.70 on 13 June.
Platinum prices had risen by 1% during the first six months of 2024 from the end of 2023. Much of that lackluster performance can be attributed to weakness in prices during the first two months of this year. Since the beginning of March platinum prices have been moving higher at a gentle pace.
The support for platinum comes primarily from the expectation that total supply, which is comprised of both mine as well as scrap supply, will decline this year. While the expected weakness in total platinum supply is supportive of prices, total fabrication demand is projected to weaken during 2024 as well, albeit at a slower pace than the projected decline in total supply.
The forecast weakness in fabrication demand for 2024 is expected to act as a headwind to platinum prices. While platinum prices could rise over the remainder of the year, the gains are unlikely to be particularly strong. There also is a risk of economic growth slowing more strongly during the second half of this year, which could negatively affect business sentiment, causing a pull back on commercial vehicle sales and a greater weakness in fabrication demand than is presently expected.
Over the next couple of months platinum prices are projected to move in a sideways fashion. Prices are expected to move between $950 and $1,065. If prices break support a decline toward $905 or even $880 is possible. On the upside, if resistance is broken prices could rise toward $1,100.
Palladium was the only exchange traded precious metal that ended April lower than where it started the month. While all precious metals softened during the second half of April, palladium prices took a particularly bad hit because its fundamentals and consequently investor sentiment toward the metal are negative. The weakness at the end of April has continued into early May. It would not be surprising to see palladium prices retest $860 in the near term.
While market participants are not thrilled about the prospects of palladium at this time, the slowdown in battery electric vehicles (BEVs) adoption in various markets provides a lifeline for the metal at least in the short term. The Chinese vehicle scrappage program which took effect starting 1 May incentivizes Chinese consumers to scrap their old vehicles for electric vehicles. This will to some extent offset lower adoption of electric vehicles in other markets. The Chinese government is also offering a smaller incentive to consumers that are looking to scrap their old internal combustion engines (ICEs) for new smaller ICEs.
The massive amounts of above ground palladium inventories coupled with new palladium capacity coming onstream and the shrinkage of demand from the auto sector are all factors that are expected to weigh on palladium prices.
Seasonal weakness and overall softness in other precious metals are expected to drive palladium lower in the short term. While $860 is the first support level, any weakness in economic growth as the year progresses which would weigh on auto and industrial demand could drive palladium prices lower, possibly toward $800.
Fabrication Demand
China’s passenger vehicle demand held up fairly well during the first quarter of 2024, rising 11% over the corresponding period in 2023. Part of the reason for the healthy demand is the comparison to a relatively weak period of demand and part of the reason is an uptick in economic activity in China.
Passenger vehicle demand is estimated to have softened in April, as consumers delayed purchases to take advantage of the vehicle scrappage program being introduced by the government. Per the program, those who turn in their old ICE or electric vehicles for new electric vehicles will be eligible to receive a 10,000-yuan subsidy.
While this is likely to increase China’s passenger vehicle demand, it will hurt palladium prices in two ways. One, the increased demand for electric vehicles in China means less palladium being used by the Chinese auto industry. Second, the scrappage of old ICE vehicles will mean an increase in platinum group metal (PGM) scrap which are palladium-intense in China. The Chinese government is also offering a smaller incentive of 7,000 yuan to consumers that are looking to scrap their old ICEs for new smaller ICEs. While this is less negative than the electric vehicle scheme, the new ICE vehicles will be smaller, which means holding all other factors that influence PGM loadings in catalysts constant, the smaller engines will require lesser PGMs. Furthermore, this scheme will also increase the amount of PGM available for scrap.
The below report was created for Monex Precious Metals. We would like to thank Monex for making this CPM Group report available free of charge.
The below report was created for Monex Precious Metals. We would like to thank Monex for making this CPM Group report available free of charge.
The below report was created for Monex Precious Metals. We would like to thank Monex for making this CPM Group report available free of charge.